Arielle Roemer
Bright renovated loft living room with exposed brick, tall windows, a timber beam and understated neutral furnishings.

What Old City Condo Buyers Are Choosing Between in 2026

November 19, 2026

"I'm not looking at studios at all, and one-bedrooms for the condos is not good," developer Virgis Anusauskas told a community meeting in September. The Philadelphia Inquirer reported the remark. He was describing a proposed seven-story, 43-unit building at 148 N. Second St. in Old City, on a corner where restaurant supply stores used to be.

That one sentence explains a good deal about Old City's condo market heading into winter. In the same article the Inquirer called Old City "one of the few neighborhoods that still sees condo development." The new buildings going up here are designed around space. The resale market includes condos in converted industrial buildings, such as a loft one-bedroom on Chestnut Street that was listed this month. A buyer looking in Old City this fall is really choosing between two products, and each is priced on its own terms.

Why Downtown Has So Many Small Apartments

Both products come back to the rental market. Downtown Philadelphia has spent a decade adding apartments faster than almost anywhere. The Center City District's 2026 Center City Housing Report, released Sept. 14, found that Core Center City's apartment stock grew about 3.8% a year from 2016 onward. Over the same stretch, rents rose about 1.4% a year, which works out to an inflation-adjusted decline of roughly 15%. The report puts Core Center City vacancy at 8% and found that office-to-residential conversions now make up most new housing in the core.

Most of that new space came in small units. In August 2024, the Inquirer reported citywide apartment vacancy above 10%, up from 5.7% in 2021, with some landlords offering up to two months of free rent. A year later, in October 2025, the paper reported that post-pandemic apartment construction in Philadelphia still leaned heavily toward studios and one-bedrooms.

That matters to a condo buyer because renting is the alternative to buying. Someone weighing a one-bedroom condo downtown can rent a newer one-bedroom nearby, often in a building with a gym and a roof deck, at rents that have fallen in real terms for years. That puts a ceiling on what a small condo can sell for. A two- or three-bedroom unit in a small historic building faces much less competition from rentals, because few rental buildings have them. Anusauskas made the same point in the Inquirer's September article. He said so many studios and one-bedrooms have gone up in Philadelphia's central neighborhoods that he sees demand for larger units, and that the size of the rental supply may leave an opening for selling them as condominiums.

What Old City Is Building to Sell

The new Old City projects are small buildings with large homes inside them.

The plan for 148 N. Second St. calls for mostly two-bedroom units of about 900 square feet, plus three three-bedroom units of 1,100 to 1,500 square feet on the top floors. It also includes about 1,400 square feet of commercial space and 15 parking spaces. Two historic buildings, at 148 and 150 N. Second, would be kept and built into the project, with the taller sections set back so they don't loom over them. Gnome Architects designed it. The plan was scheduled for an Oct. 28 Zoning Board of Adjustment hearing on a height of about 77 feet, where the base zoning allows 65. Anusauskas has said he is keeping the option to rent or sell the units.

The Curator, at 225 Quarry St. and 151 N. Third St., is further along. Philly YIMBY reported in August 2024 that its units were planned as condominiums for sale. The project's own site now lists 14 residences, mostly two- and three-bedrooms plus a five-bedroom and penthouses, with delivery targeted for 2026 and prices starting at $775,000. The Quarry Street units shown there run from a 947-square-foot one-bedroom, marked in contract, to 1,443- and 1,503-square-foot two- and three-bedrooms, and on up to 3,317 square feet.

On a narrow lot at 248 N. Lawrence St., permits were issued in May 2025 for five condominiums, one per floor, each about 1,148 square feet, according to Philly YIMBY.

All three are boutique projects of 5 to 43 units. Their plans call for full-floor homes, three-bedroom top floors and a five-bedroom penthouse, which is the larger size that, by the developers' own account, the downtown rental market has built less of.

What Is Already Standing

Old City's existing condo stock grew from a different source. The neighborhood's old factories and warehouses began turning into housing decades ago. The city's Old City Historic District inventory records the Moore Wireworks at 301–303 Race St. as a 1900 factory for insulated electric wire, converted to a residential complex in 1983–84. A few blocks north, the former Wilbur Chocolate Factory at 231–247 N. Third St. is now the Chocolate Works.

Loft homes in buildings like these are a different product from the new construction. One example appeared in the Inquirer's House of the Week on Nov. 3. It is an 890-square-foot one-bedroom on the third floor of an elevator building at 122 Chestnut St., with timber-beamed ceilings, oak floors, exposed brick, historically certified floor-to-ceiling replacement windows, and views of the Ben Franklin Bridge. The 2nd Street El stop is around the corner. When the article ran, the unit was listed at $312,999, about $352 a square foot.

A one-bedroom like this has the character of a converted industrial building, and it also competes most directly with the new downtown rentals.

How the Two Price Against Each Other

Loft resale, 122 Chestnut St. New construction, The Curator
Size 890 sq ft, 1 bedroom Listed units from 947 to 3,317 sq ft, mostly 2 and 3 bedrooms
Price Listed at $312,999 as of Nov. 3, 2026 From $775,000
Building Converted elevator loft building on a cobblestone street 14-unit new building, delivery targeted for 2026
Closest rental substitute Plentiful downtown one-bedrooms Few large rental units nearby

The gap between those two price points is about more than new versus old. The products face different competition. A one-bedroom loft is priced against every one-bedroom rental within a walk, and the Center City District's numbers show those rents falling after inflation. A new three-bedroom with parking in a 14-unit building has few direct rivals for sale or for rent. Both can be sound purchases. They will behave differently when it is time to resell, because the pool of alternatives a future buyer weighs them against is so different.

What the Regional Numbers Add

Bright MLS's regional reports show the general pattern. In Bright's October 2026 Philadelphia metro report, with data through Nov. 6, the metro median condo sale price for October was $305,000, up 1.7% year over year. Condos took a median 28 days to sell. Attached homes and townhomes had a $315,000 median, up 1.6%, and sold in a median 20 days.

The month before showed a wider gap. Bright's September 2026 metro report had September's condo median at $295,000, up 0.3% from a year earlier. Attached homes were up 8.5% and detached homes up 4.3% over the same period.

Inventory in Philadelphia County is growing. For October, Bright counted 5,701 active listings across all property types in the county, up 21.2% year over year, with 5.33 months of supply, up 1.12 months.

These are metro and county figures, not Old City figures. They are consistent with the story the developers are telling. Across the region, condos are selling more slowly than rowhomes, and their prices have grown more slowly. Buyers this fall have more to choose from than they did a year ago. In that market, the condos with the fewest substitutes have the clearest case for their price.

The Longer Horizon on the Waterfront

The time frame matters for anyone buying new construction in Old City. Anusauskas told the Inquirer that the cap over I-95 at Penn's Landing, and the park that will sit on it, make the neighborhood more appealing to him. The Park at Penn's Landing describes an 11.5-acre park under construction over I-95 and Columbus Boulevard, with opening expected in 2029 or 2030. Buyers in the pipeline projects are buying several years ahead of that park.

FAQ

Are condos still being built in Center City? In small numbers. The Inquirer described Old City in September as one of the few Philadelphia neighborhoods still seeing condo development.

Why are the new Old City condos mostly two bedrooms and up? The developers are building the unit size the rental market lacks. Downtown rental construction leaned heavily toward studios and one-bedrooms, so larger homes face less competition from apartments.

Where does a one-bedroom loft fit? A loft like the 890-square-foot unit at 122 Chestnut St. was listed near $350 a square foot on Nov. 3. It has the character of a converted industrial building, and it is priced against the many downtown one-bedroom rentals nearby.

If you are weighing a converted loft against a new two- or three-bedroom in one of Old City's boutique buildings, Arielle Roemer is glad to talk through both with you. Compare notes with our Old City loft guide, then schedule a consultation to talk through which kind of unit fits your plans.

Work With Arielle

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.